In the same way that learning to read is contingent on readiness, I believe a certain level of maturity is required to move into the more abstract concepts of math. And, as with anything, this is not necessarily associated with reaching a certain age. This is why one size education does not fit all. Some kids take longer to reach that ability. This year we seem to have finally reached a point where we can truly move forward.
This year we have seen a huge growth in maturity and a huge improvement in his ability to work with numbers. When we got stuck with Math-U-See, I decided to hop over to Easy Peasy's Middle School Math, Step 1, and work through that for a while. I had the intention of going back to Math-U-See when we got to fractions again, but he is doing pretty well with Easy Peasy. So, we're just going to keep trucking along.
We are in the "Fractions" Section of the page linked above and need to get all the way through the list (Fractions, Decimals and Percents; Ratios and Proportions; and Exponents) before we can start Algebra. So we'll be plugging away at that through the summer, and maybe into next year. But when we get through all that, we do not need to delay algebra any longer. We can dive right into VideoText Interactive's Algebra, A Complete Course, which begins with pre-algebra.
I do not expect the young man to love this program. I really don't expect him to love any program since he'd rather just not do the math. But, I do expect that he will be able to understand the math. The visual aspects of this program are a huge benefit. Another key aspect for us was the lessons being taught one small bite at a time. And the main focus is not just to learn the formulas - but to understand why you are using them.
One thing I've learned this year is the need to tackle a concept from different angles or perspectives when we get stuck. In addition to Easy Peasy, I also have a subscription to Math Antics. When we get stuck, I have him pop over there and view how Rob and Jeremy teach the concept and work through the printable worksheets. Then we pop back over to Kahn Academy and do the lesson there again. It has also been very helpful to have our math tutor friend go over concepts his way from time to time.
I intend to continue to use this strategy once we move into algebra. We will work through VideoText and utilize Math Antics and other resources (Kahn Academy, YouTube) when we get stuck. And hopefully, our math tutor friend will continue to be available. He has been a Godsend.
I hope sharing some of our math stories is encouraging to others that have similar struggles. Mainly, be patient. Your struggling student may just need to grow and mature. Continue to provide opportunities to work with numbers in real life and try lots of different strategies for figuring things out. Even if you find you are dealing with dyscalculia, I believe your student can, in time, learn how to live in a world of numbers.